Question marks still remain over McIlroy’s mettle

John Craven

Rory McIlroy (Photo by Christian Petersen/Getty Images)

Far be it from me to hold a grudge but I’ll never forget the first comment posted under a column I wrote in August last year entitled, ‘Question marks remain over McIlroy’s mettle’. Admittedly I recognised that the timing of it – just days after Rory had won the $15 million FedEx Cup prize – was going to stoke the fire but I didn’t expect the first comment from Joe Bloggs to name check me and demand that my position at the magazine be seriously considered. Here I was, a hack with a weekly column spouting opinion like some sort of… well, hack with a weekly column. I mean, the cheek of me when I think about it…

But the reason I dredge the canal of my memories and bring this back up is… and you’ll never guess what… question marks remain over McIlroy’s mettle! You couldn’t make it up, only I did, just over a year ago. Of course, I’m not alone in seeing a pattern with McIlroy’s play over the last few years, and this isn’t an exercise in saying ‘I told ya so’ (although it kinda is), but I can’t help the frustration I feel following McIlroy’s career, particularly after tournaments where he posts 29 birdies and somehow finishes outside the top-15, like he did last week at Sherwood.

On his day, I remain a firm believer that McIlroy is so much better than the rest, but his day doesn’t fall at the Majors anymore and as much and all as I hope he wins at Augusta next month and joins the immortal group of Grand Slam champions, I just don’t see it… not this year anyway… and the main reason is because deep down, I know how much it would mean to him, and that’s a lot of pressure – an almighty test of mettle, some might say.


For those of you interested in the article that had my head on the chopping block, it’s pasted below. Call it lazy journalism, in my eyes, it’s as relevant today as it was when penned last year. But don’t tell Joe Bloggs that, or he’ll have me sacked. Again!

  • Question marks remain over McIlroy’s mettle

‘Far be it from me to bring things crashing back down to earth after a man’s just won $15million and completed his most consistent season on the PGA Tour to date, but I’m quite confident Rory McIlroy won’t be reading this article any time soon.

First thing’s first; fair play to the new FedExCup champion for showing up to work this week in Switzerland for the European Masters. I know he’s only playing golf but this is the equivalent of you or me winning the lotto and turning up to the office the next morning. Kudos on the belated European Tour commitment, Rory.

Make no mistake about it, Sunday at East Lake was vintage McIlroy as he dismantled the field to win by four and take home more money than he’ll ever need to spend, but by his own admission, the Tour Championship will never be the acid test of McIlroy.

“Who knows what the winner wins at the Masters?” He told reporters pre-tournament. “I don’t know because that’s not what it’s about.  “If the FedExCup wants to create a legacy that lasts longer, it doesn’t need to be about the money. It should be about the prestige of winning an event that you’ll be remembered for.” 

Given Sunday lacked those pertinent ingredients, it meant McIlroy was able to play with a freedom of mind that’s been missing from five years of shortcomings at the sport’s four Majors. Unfortunately, as resounding as his Sunday saunter proved, the wounds of McIlroy’s Portrush meltdown won’t fully heal until he gets over the line for a fifth Major title.

Which makes the calls lauding 2019 as Rory McIlroy’s best ever year quite extraordinary. From a consistency standpoint, sure, you can make the argument but Rory McIlroy won’t be remembered for how many top-10’s he compiled this year, or for the amount of dollars he banked off the back of it. He’ll be remembered for how many Majors he claimed – a grand total of zero, and with each passing year, that concern intensifies to the detriment of his play.

2014 remains McIlroy’s best year, a double Major winning return that set him up for so many more. The fact that he still sits at four is evidence enough that the Majors are a point of genuine worry for McIlroy and there’s no reason to suggest that a FedExCup win will prove the catalyst in bucking this trend.

In 2016, McIlroy won the Tour Championship and the then $10million bonus in a performance that signalled his revival following two years of Major disappointment. The following April, rounds of 72 and 73 meant his Grand Slam challenge never got off the ground as the Green Jacket went to Garcia at Augusta National. A 78 in round one of the US Open and a missed cut later wasn’t much better while he was five-over through six holes at The Open before then caddie, JP Fitzgerald had to remind McIlroy of who he was. Such a time for an identity crisis.

But in many ways, therein lies the problem; McIlroy’s lost his golfing identity. Perhaps the comforting thing is that in this, his most self-reflective year, the 30-year old is beginning to realise it too. The handicapping system of the Tour finale may have been somewhat flawed last week but it played to Rory’s advantage. Starting from five back, McIlroy was forced to morph into the golfer who had stormed to four Majors by the age of 25; carefree and aggressive.

These days, McIlroy’s best golf, time and time again, spawns from a place of desperation. Take the Open; his Friday flash through the field was sparked by lost hope. That doesn’t necessarily solve the problem; he can’t rise from the ashes of a Thursday morning, but he should realise that his golfing gift allows him to play like few others can; without regard for safety. It’s when McIlroy attacks a golf course with little respect for its designer that he produces his best stuff. It’s counter-intuitive for someone of his mercurial talents to play conservatively and if he can somehow take this mindset – one of a cocksure showman who doesn’t know any better– into the Majors next year, then maybe, like his main rival, Brooks Koepka, Rory can eye double-digit Majors before his career is done.

Just one word of advice, Rory. Whether you find the secret to unlocking your mind to the Majors once more or not, don’t speak a word of it in the lead up to the tournament. As Ronan Keating sings to himself on the first tee of a Sunday morning, ‘you play it best, when you say nothing at all’.


Stay ahead of the game. Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest Irish Golfer news straight to your inbox!

More News

2 responses to “Question marks still remain over McIlroy’s mettle”

  1. Don Hanley NIRELAND avatar
    Don Hanley NIRELAND

    How true So Rory bitten it and go blow the field away and excitement all your fans again and again

  2. Don Hanley NIRELAND avatar
    Don Hanley NIRELAND

    How true So Rory button it and go blow the field away and excitement all your fans again and again

Leave a comment

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy & Terms of Service apply.