GUI & ILGU issue joint statement regarding competitions queries

by | Jun 6, 2020 | 12 comments

IrishGolfer.ie

Must Read

Following the dramatic u-turn in terms of competitive golf which was confirmed by the GUI and ILGU late on Friday evening and the subsequent flood of questions and outrage online from golfers around the country, the Governing bodies of golf have now made a clarifying statement on the matter.

The statement clears up some questions in relation to the late change of heart but it is little comfort for the many clubs, administrators and volunteers that had put considerable time, effort and financial investment into getting courses and procedures ready for the re-introduction of competition.

It would appear that the Governing bodies have been required to implement the advice from the Expert Group on the Return to Sport but the decision will raise more questions as the ‘no competitions’ regulation only applies to the Republic of Ireland, so competitions in Northern Ireland are still on the cards.

On the positive side, the fact that we can travel within our counties or within 20km of our homes from Monday should mean that most golfers can now get to play.

JOINT RESPONSE TO QUERIES ON COMPETITIONS BY GUI & ILGU
Please note: This relates to golf clubs in the Republic of Ireland only.​

In mid-April the GUI and ILGU submitted a draft Protocol to Government which outlined the means by which the Unions felt that golf could be re-introduced on a safe, low-risk basis. This submission by the Unions ultimately led to golf being included, as one of only two named sports, in Phase 1 of the Government’s Roadmap for Reopening Society and Business.

Once the Unions became aware of the phased approach taken by Government, Golf’s Protocol was updated to include phases matching those in the Government’s Roadmap and the Union’s submitted their updated Protocol to Government, including an Appendix setting out Golf’s phased plan. The Appendix indicated that Club competitions would be allowed in Phase 2.
The GUI and ILGU then issued the Protocol to clubs and golfers, emphasising that:
“Public health measures are likely to be continually updated by the Government. Even if golf continues to be allowed in such circumstances, the Protocol governing the safe playing of the game may be updated in line with any changes to public health measures.”
Phase 1 of Golf’s Protocol was subsequently approved by the Government appointed Expert Group on the Return to Sport. Feedback from the group was silent in relation to Phase 2 and subsequent phases.
On the week commencing 25th May, the Unions submitted their detailed Protocol for Phase 2 to Government, including some easing in restrictions relating to group sizes and tee-time intervals, indicating that the Protocol would be published and issued to affiliated clubs on Monday, 1st June.
On Wednesday, 3rd June, the Expert Group on the Return to Sport met and considered Phase 2 protocols from various sports. At this meeting, the Group decided that competitions across all team and individual sports would not be permitted in Phase 2. This was communicated to the Unions on Thursday, 4th June.
Clearly, the Unions remained of the view that golf competitions, played under that conditions set out in Appendix 2 of the Unions Phase 2 Protocol, posed no additional risk to golfers. This was communicated to Sport Ireland on the afternoon of Thursday, 4th June and Sport Ireland were asked to reconsider the position.
On the afternoon of Friday, 5th June, Sport Ireland confirmed the decision of the Expert Group, as follows:
“An important point is that the Expert Group advises against any competitive sport in Phase 2. That is a general point across all sports and not directed at golf specifically although relevant to your plans. Fairness and consistency of the application of advice across all sport is an important element of the mandate of the Expert Group.
There is a rationale behind that advice. Phase 2 remains a high risk Phase with COVID 19 still active in community settings. People are encouraged to return to sport and physical activity but strictly within public health guidelines. There are significant relaxations of the protocols but caution is still recommended. Competition in sport is not advised as it means higher intensity activity, more people involved in a particular event and an incentive for people to travel beyond the 20 km limit.
We understand your point that closed club competitions were included in protocols submitted some weeks ago. However, the Expert Group works on a Phase by Phase basis as the public health advice can change. Phase 2 was only considered on June 3 and it is understood that the public health emergency is an evolving situation with a high level of uncertainty from week to week. NGBs have to plan ahead but those plans are subject to change depending on Government approval and advice.”
The Unions then issued their statement to clubs confirming that competitions could not be played in Phase 2.
On the morning of Saturday, 6th June, the Department of Transport, Tourism and Sport issued a Press Release (See: https://www.gov.ie/en/press-release/c7327-return-to-sport-expert-group-recommends-further-steps-towards-phase-2-protocols/) confirming the decision of the Expert Group. The Press Release states:
“On this occasion, the Expert Group emphasized that the resumption of permitted sporting activity under phase 2 related to team sports training (but not matches) where social distancing can be maintained and where there is no contact. The focus is on team training, not on the playing of team games.
Accordingly, the Expert Group confirmed that training matches, friendlies, competitive fixtures or competitions in individual or team sport are not included under phase two; these will arise in later phases.”
The GUI and ILGU acknowledge the work of the Expert Group in the complex matter of  getting sport re-started in a safe manner and particularly, for the progressive approach the Group has taken in deciding that golf would be included from Phase 1. We will continue to work with the Group as we progress through the Roadmap.
The Unions welcome the easing of travel restrictions from 8th June, and their proposed elimination from Phase 3, which will allow increased access to golf courses and the potential for additional revenue generation from green fees.
Finally, we would like to commend our member clubs and golfers for the manner in which they have embraced Golf’s Protocol during Phase 1 and we welcome the fact that our game continues to provide an outlet to people in these challenging times.

Stay ahead of the game. Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest Irish Golfer news straight to your inbox!

12 Comments

  1. Chris Thompson

    What is the extra risk of the spread of the virus between casual golf and competition golf. Neither is a “team” sport.

    Reply
  2. Pat

    Sport Ireland have no idea about real competitive golf. How do they think we can’t social distance in social golf and not in competitive golf.

    Reply
  3. J ken

    Another bunch of wasters to add to a growing list.utter stupidity from S.I.

    Reply
  4. John

    It seems to me that the reference in the Expert Groups Statement to no competitions should be read only in relation to sporting activities that are now allowed to be resumed under Phase 2 and not to golf which is already allowed to be played casually under Phase 1.
    The Department seems to have made a mistake in their interpretation- having regard to the specific context.
    I hope it admits to that .Holding internal golf competitions does not expose players to any additional risk because the physical contact conditions remain the same.
    It should be at the discretion of each Club as to whether or not

    Reply
  5. Frank

    you would think it is the end of the world with the way people have reacted to the No Competitions for the next 3 weeks,
    we should still feel grateful to be out playing golf.
    you should all look at your time sheets from the last 3 weeks and see how well your golf clubs managed with the initial protocols, if no one from outside 5k played then you can gripe. you have a legitimate case to argue to bring back comps.
    also heard many give out that horse racing is back.
    it is a professional sport. point to point (amateurs) are not back.
    HRI submitted a 77 page document and it took a huge amount of work to get them back, including input from doctors, vets, Health and safety people.
    tell me when your committees came up with the ideas for reintroduction of comps, did they consult doctors, do risk assessments, draw up safety strategies. then brief all those involved.
    its another 3 weeks folks, you can wait till then for your 0.1’s

    Reply
    • Danny

      Frank, I suggest that you are missing the point here. The vast majority of golf clubs depend heavily of the income generated by competition golf. The protocols regarding the medical elements in Phase 1 are exactly the same as in Phase 2. The same protocols apply players in round sof casual golf ans they do in competition golf. Club committees have put a lot of thought and effort into ensuring that competitive golf could gop ahead from 8 June only to have the rug pulled from under them by GUI/ILGU.

      Reply
  6. Ciaran kelly

    So horse racing and greyhound racing gets the green light from today … how patethic.. the bookmakers run this country

    Reply
  7. John Stokes

    What a waste of time reading that was. No logical health or other reason given for the decision. A load of utter balderdash.

    Reply
  8. Tim

    The only conclusion from this sorry shambles is the inability and failure of the GUI to convince the NPHET or Sport Ireland of the absolute safety of playing golf in the wide open spaces of a golf course. It’s like getting a penalty in football with no goalkeeper and not scoring.
    The new entity which will come about with the amalgamation of GUI and ILGU will require as an absolute ‘must’, a CEO with a proven record of leadership, strategic, management and communication skills as befits the running of a 21st century organisation.

    Reply
  9. Peter Whelan

    It defies logic that from 8 June an additional golfer can be added to make up fourballs but competitive golf is a non-runner. Is the marking of a scorecard more of a risk factor than the extra golfer in the group? As a competition secretary I worked with my committee to draw up a practical and safe methodology for dealing with competition and score entry into the system and also the subsequent checking of the scores if required. In fact we had most of this in place prior to the shutdown. I am not aware of any of the committee or members contracting as much as a common cold. I can only hope that Golf Ireland will provide better representation for golfers in the future. GUI you should be embarassed!!!

    Reply
  10. Golfer

    Another load of blah from the gui etc to camouflage their obvious incompetence. A blind man on a galloping horse could see that golf was an outdoors sport which could quite easily abide with the social distancing guidelines, from start of “lockdown”.
    Yet the gui executive appear to have given themselves a pat on the back whilst golf clubs throughout the country are struggling financially. The gui etc have obviously lost their sense of reality & are totally detached from the people who pay them & supposedly represent , golf club members.

    Reply
  11. Danny

    What a load of waffle! The GUI/ILGU should hold their heads in shame.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Stay ahead of the game. Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest Irish Golfer news straight to your inbox!

12 Comments

  1. Chris Thompson

    What is the extra risk of the spread of the virus between casual golf and competition golf. Neither is a “team” sport.

    Reply
  2. Pat

    Sport Ireland have no idea about real competitive golf. How do they think we can’t social distance in social golf and not in competitive golf.

    Reply
  3. J ken

    Another bunch of wasters to add to a growing list.utter stupidity from S.I.

    Reply
  4. John

    It seems to me that the reference in the Expert Groups Statement to no competitions should be read only in relation to sporting activities that are now allowed to be resumed under Phase 2 and not to golf which is already allowed to be played casually under Phase 1.
    The Department seems to have made a mistake in their interpretation- having regard to the specific context.
    I hope it admits to that .Holding internal golf competitions does not expose players to any additional risk because the physical contact conditions remain the same.
    It should be at the discretion of each Club as to whether or not

    Reply
  5. Frank

    you would think it is the end of the world with the way people have reacted to the No Competitions for the next 3 weeks,
    we should still feel grateful to be out playing golf.
    you should all look at your time sheets from the last 3 weeks and see how well your golf clubs managed with the initial protocols, if no one from outside 5k played then you can gripe. you have a legitimate case to argue to bring back comps.
    also heard many give out that horse racing is back.
    it is a professional sport. point to point (amateurs) are not back.
    HRI submitted a 77 page document and it took a huge amount of work to get them back, including input from doctors, vets, Health and safety people.
    tell me when your committees came up with the ideas for reintroduction of comps, did they consult doctors, do risk assessments, draw up safety strategies. then brief all those involved.
    its another 3 weeks folks, you can wait till then for your 0.1’s

    Reply
    • Danny

      Frank, I suggest that you are missing the point here. The vast majority of golf clubs depend heavily of the income generated by competition golf. The protocols regarding the medical elements in Phase 1 are exactly the same as in Phase 2. The same protocols apply players in round sof casual golf ans they do in competition golf. Club committees have put a lot of thought and effort into ensuring that competitive golf could gop ahead from 8 June only to have the rug pulled from under them by GUI/ILGU.

      Reply
  6. Ciaran kelly

    So horse racing and greyhound racing gets the green light from today … how patethic.. the bookmakers run this country

    Reply
  7. John Stokes

    What a waste of time reading that was. No logical health or other reason given for the decision. A load of utter balderdash.

    Reply
  8. Tim

    The only conclusion from this sorry shambles is the inability and failure of the GUI to convince the NPHET or Sport Ireland of the absolute safety of playing golf in the wide open spaces of a golf course. It’s like getting a penalty in football with no goalkeeper and not scoring.
    The new entity which will come about with the amalgamation of GUI and ILGU will require as an absolute ‘must’, a CEO with a proven record of leadership, strategic, management and communication skills as befits the running of a 21st century organisation.

    Reply
  9. Peter Whelan

    It defies logic that from 8 June an additional golfer can be added to make up fourballs but competitive golf is a non-runner. Is the marking of a scorecard more of a risk factor than the extra golfer in the group? As a competition secretary I worked with my committee to draw up a practical and safe methodology for dealing with competition and score entry into the system and also the subsequent checking of the scores if required. In fact we had most of this in place prior to the shutdown. I am not aware of any of the committee or members contracting as much as a common cold. I can only hope that Golf Ireland will provide better representation for golfers in the future. GUI you should be embarassed!!!

    Reply
  10. Golfer

    Another load of blah from the gui etc to camouflage their obvious incompetence. A blind man on a galloping horse could see that golf was an outdoors sport which could quite easily abide with the social distancing guidelines, from start of “lockdown”.
    Yet the gui executive appear to have given themselves a pat on the back whilst golf clubs throughout the country are struggling financially. The gui etc have obviously lost their sense of reality & are totally detached from the people who pay them & supposedly represent , golf club members.

    Reply
  11. Danny

    What a load of waffle! The GUI/ILGU should hold their heads in shame.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Latest News